Gildan vs Bella Canvas vs Independent Trading: Wholesale Hoodie Comparison

Gildan vs Bella Canvas vs Independent Trading hoodie cover graphic

Compare the Gildan 18500, Bella+Canvas 3719 and Independent Trading Company IND4000 by exact style and colorway. The 3719 weighs 8.0 oz and uses 52/48 cotton-poly fleece in solids. The 10 oz IND4000 uses 70/30 cotton-poly fleece with a 100% cotton face on solids. Test the selected blank with your artwork and decoration process before ordering.

Last verified: April 2026. Specs vary by colorway and may change. Confirm current details with manufacturers before ordering.

Why These Three Hoodies?

These three styles consistently rank among the highest-volume wholesale hoodies in North America. Each represents a distinct tier and philosophy in blank apparel manufacturing. The Gildan 18500 is the lowest-cost option. The Bella+Canvas 3719 targets the fashion-forward retail-quality segment. The ITC IND4000 is heavyweight at 10 oz, the starting point for that category. The table below lists weight, blend, fit and price tier for each, so you can match the blank to your decoration method and budget.

Head-to-Head Comparison Table

Specification Gildan 18500 Bella+Canvas 3719 ITC IND4000
Weight 8.0 oz (271 GSM) 8.0 oz (271 GSM, converted) 10.0 oz (330 GSM)
Fabric Blend 50% Cotton / 50% Polyester 52/48 Airlume cotton-poly fleece in solids. Athletic Heather is 90/10. 70/30 cotton-poly (solids, 100% cotton face). Blends vary by colorway
Fit Classic / Relaxed Retail / Unisex Comfortable Standard / Slightly Relaxed
Construction Classic body Side-seamed Split-stitch double-needle sewing
Hood Double-lined, color-matched drawcord Hood with drawcord Double-lined, matching flat drawcord
Pocket Pouch pocket Pouch pocket Pouch pocket
Color Range 50+ colors 30+ colors 40+ colors
Price Tier Budget tier Mid-Range tier Mid-Premium tier
Best For High-volume events, fundraisers, budget promotions Retail brands, DTC labels, fashion-forward clients Streetwear brands, premium decorators, resale

Gildan 18500: The Budget Standard

What It Does Well

The Gildan 18500 Heavy Blend Hooded Sweatshirt is the default choice when cost-per-unit is the primary concern. At a low wholesale cost depending on quantity and color, it is the lowest-cost option in this comparison. Its 50/50 cotton-poly blend resists shrinkage effectively, and the 8.0 oz weight provides decent warmth without feeling overly heavy. With over 50 colors available, Gildan’s supply chain ensures that even niche shades are typically in stock at major distributors.

Where It Falls Short

The 50/50 blend produces a noticeably synthetic hand-feel compared to higher-cotton alternatives. Screen printers working with water-based or discharge inks will find the polyester content limiting. These inks perform best on fabrics with 80% cotton or higher. The fit runs boxy and large, which can look dated next to more modern silhouettes. For brands targeting a younger, fashion-conscious demographic, the 18500 may undermine the perceived value of the finished product.

Brands weighing this kind of trade-off across suppliers can find a broader framework in our guide to choosing the best wholesale hoodie supplier for their brand.

Decoration Compatibility

Plastisol screen printing performs adequately. DTG results are inconsistent across many colorways due to the high poly content, not just on heathers. Embroidery works well given the fabric density. DTF transfers adhere reliably. Discharge printing is not recommended.

Bella+Canvas 3719: The Retail-Quality Contender

What It Does Well

The Bella+Canvas 3719 Unisex Sponge Fleece Pullover Hoodie targets brands that need retail-quality blanks. The Bella+Canvas 3719 uses 52% Airlume combed ringspun cotton and 48% polyester fleece in solid colorways. Athletic Heather uses a 90/10 blend. The fit is a retail-fit unisex hoodie that photographs well for DTC brands selling online. The 3719 weighs 8.0 oz and uses 32-singles yarn.

Where It Falls Short

At 8.0 oz, it is a lighter-feel hoodie in the comparison. Customers expecting a heavyweight, substantial feel will be disappointed. It is a fashion layer, not an outerwear piece. The mid-range wholesale price point also means tighter margins for high-volume promotional work. The color range, while curated, is smaller than Gildan’s, which can be a limitation for buyers who need specific color alignment with brand requirements.

Decoration Compatibility

DTG printing produces excellent results on the soft, smooth face. Screen printing with water-based inks works well for the cotton-forward blend. The lighter weight means heavy plastisol deposits can feel stiff against the fabric. Embroidery is possible but requires careful stabilization due to the softer fleece. DTF transfers perform well.

Independent Trading Company IND4000: The Streetwear Favorite

What It Does Well

The ITC IND4000 is the heavyweight option in this comparison. Standard solid colorways use a 70/30 cotton-poly blend with a 100% cotton face at 10.0 oz, delivering a substantial hand-feel. The high cotton content on solids makes it a strong performer for water-based and discharge printing, producing vibrant, soft-hand results. The fit strikes a balance, relaxed enough for layering but not so oversized that it loses shape after washing. The flat drawcord and clean pocket construction give it a polished, contemporary look. Note that heathers, camo, and safety colors use different blends. Evaluate performance by colorway.

Where It Falls Short

The higher cotton content means more shrinkage potential, so buyers should communicate care instructions clearly. At the highest wholesale price point in this comparison, it is the most expensive option in this comparison. For budget-conscious programs like school fundraisers or large-scale corporate giveaways, the cost difference over a Gildan 18500 adds up quickly across hundreds of units.

Decoration Compatibility

Screen printing across all ink types (plastisol, water-based, discharge) performs cleanly on solid colorways with the cotton face. DTG produces sharp, detailed results on the cotton-rich surface. Embroidery holds up well at 10 oz. DTF transfers bond securely. Discharge performance is heavily fiber- and dye-dependent, so test per colorway before committing to bulk runs. If your shop’s margin depends on print quality, the IND4000 gives you the fewest variables to manage on standard solids.

So Which Hoodie Should You Stock?

The answer depends entirely on your customer base and business model:

  • Stock the Gildan 18500 if your primary revenue comes from high-volume, price-sensitive orders, events, schools, nonprofit fundraisers, and large corporate runs where per-unit cost is the deciding factor.
  • Stock the Bella+Canvas 3719 if your customers are DTC brands, boutique labels, or any client who prioritizes soft hand-feel, modern fit, and retail-ready presentation over raw durability.
  • Stock the ITC IND4000 if your shop specializes in premium decoration, streetwear collaborations, or resale-quality blanks where print performance and fabric weight are non-negotiable.

Other Options Worth Considering

While this breakdown covers the most commonly ordered styles, the wholesale market has expanded significantly. Buyers looking for heavier options should consider blanks in the 10-12 oz range. The Three Layer Sportswear P280 offers a 70/30 cotton-poly blend at 8.8 oz with a clean print canvas. The Three Layer 15001 at 12 oz competes directly with premium brands like Pro Club and Camber while offering competitive wholesale pricing.

The wholesale hoodie market rewards buyers who match the blank to the end use. There is no single “best” hoodie, only the best hoodie for a specific application. Use the comparison table above as your quick reference, order samples from your top two choices, and run your standard decoration process on both before committing to a full order.

Compare Three Layer hoodie weights and current color availability on our wholesale hoodies category page.

Wholesale blank apparel, designed in Los Angeles

Three Layer Sportswear supplies blank, undecorated apparel to screen printers, clothing brands, and merch companies. We offer no minimum ordering from January through September. During our busy season, October through December, please order single sizes in packs of 6 (one polybag) per color, per size. Orders placed by 12pm PT ship the same day, with 1 to 2 day delivery across Southern California. Visits to our Los Angeles location at 170 W 39th St are by appointment only. First time customers create a wholesale account online first, then visit to see samples and place an order in person. Repeat customers place orders at least 2 hours before pickup. Custom and private label production runs about 120 days.

Pricing is wholesale and customer specific. See live inventory and your pricing inside the NuOrder portal after logging in. For wholesale access, contact sales@threelayer.com.

Login Create Account